The Psychology Behind Underinsurance: Insights & Solutions

Aug 21 2025 15:00

Robert Routt

Does this sound familiar? You’ve been meaning to get life insurance, but somehow it never becomes a top priority. You're not alone. Many people share this hesitation, and it’s not just about procrastination or neglect. There are deeper psychological factors at play that can keep us from securing life insurance, even when we know it's important.

Understanding Normalcy Bias

Normalcy bias is the assumption that because something hasn’t happened before, it likely won’t in the future. This belief can trick us into thinking that extraordinary events like unexpected illness or accidents are just things that happen to others. For many, the comfort of daily routines and past experiences where everything was fine fosters a false sense of security, leading them to delay buying insurance.

Recognizing Optimism Bias

Optimism bias makes us believe that we’re less at risk of experiencing negative events compared to others. It’s a natural part of our mental makeup to think “it won’t happen to me.” While this positive outlook helps reduce anxiety, it also contributes to a tendency to overlook the significance of insurance, assuming health and prosperity will continue unabated.

Tackling Cost Misperception

A significant 72% of Americans overestimate the cost of life insurance, which acts as a mental barrier. Many assume life insurance policies are more expensive than they actually are, making it easy to put off looking into it. Yet, many policies are quite affordable and accessible, providing peace of mind at a surprisingly reasonable cost.

Understanding these psychological tendencies is the first step toward overcoming them. By being aware of these biases, you can take more confident and informed steps toward securing your financial future. Consider reaching out for a quote, researching your options, or even just starting a conversation about life insurance. Doing so could be your first step towards protecting yourself and your loved ones with the coverage you truly need.